as confidential. The union campaign among 2200 workers at Fuyao Glass, during which the UAW complained that workers had faced a a barrage of anti-labor tactics and intimidation, was the subject of the academy-award winning documentary, American Factory, in which the company president talked about firing union supporters. Open communication between employer, employees is crucial for maintaining a healthy working environment. E-mail or other means of communication), do not disclose information you regard You need to emphasize to employees from the beginning that a third party is never necessary when there is a problem. Chicago, IL 60611. 2. Finding new ways to help clients identify solutions and new business opportunities, across industries, is at our core. The leaked records include a spreadsheet of anecdotal personal information the company had gathered . Having worked with both union and nonunion companies over the past 30 years, our labor and employment consulting firm . Brown has repeatedly lobbied for and written in support of rule changes under the Trump Administration that would have facilitated decertification under the Railway Labor Act. 6.Fisher Phillips, International Employment Practice Group, available at https://www.fisherphillips.com/services-international-employment. Union avoidance law firms have advocated using the OECD Guidelines on Multinational Corporations to attack global union federations, cautioned corporations against signing international framework agreements that limit their union avoidance options, and argued that, under ILO jurisprudence, employers have not just a right but an obligation to campaign against unionization and collective bargaining. Whether you choose one-on-one mentoring, group training, or The Union-Free Privilege Academy, our union avoidance management consultants tailor seminars and workshops to meet the specific needs of your organization. What should you do next- The PRO Act has already encountered stiff opposition, but if Amazons conduct at Bessemer comes under intense public scrutiny, this time could be different. Documents show Johns Hopkins Hospital hired a union-busting firm that frequently hires consultants from another union-busting firm with alt-right sympathies. With centuries of combined labor relations experience, our consultants equip you with the knowledge you need. This same billionaire class, including some of the very . Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Google's Union-Busting Methods Revealed. (312) 836-0100. Littler opted for overseas offices rather than forming international alliances with overseas firms in order to provide clients with a coordinated service. The U.S. branch operates as a separate financial entity, but Littler Global is really trying to be one firm.3. 3. When it comes to unionizing, many can . 4 (December 2006), pp. In common with other union avoidance firm, ECLR claims an overwhelmingly positive victory rate in union campaigns: While unions typically win between 60 and 70% of union representation elections, ECLR maintains a win rate of over 95%. Chaired by Jackson Lewis attorneys and headquartered in Brussels, L&E Global now has over twenty partner law firms and offers services in over 25 jurisdictions spanning six continents, including the European Union, Australia, Brazil, India, and China. Union avoidance is a multi-million dollar business. The nations third and fourth largest management-side law firms specializing in union avoidance, Jackson Lewis and Fisher Phillips, have adopted a different model of international expansion. Littler attorneys have suggested using the OECD complaints process . Human Rights Watch has criticized captive meetings as a form of legal intimidation, which are unlawful in many developed democracies. Oregon enacted such a law since 2010, and in November 2020 the Trump NLRB sued for a second time to overturn the law, which has thus far not been actively enforced. Unions have filed OECD complaints during several global organizing campaigns, including those at Nissan, T-Mobile, DHL, and Ikea. He has published widely on employer opposition to unionization and on anti-union law and consultant firms. Advertisement. 310-284-3894, F Unfortunately, as critical as the supervisors role is, our union relations consultants have found that many companies spend very little time training and educating their supervisors. In 2017, for example, NATERAs annual conference included a pre-conference workshop featuring union avoidance and campaign simulation, run by the anti-union law firm, Jackson Lewis, which was tailored to the transportation industry.. Firefox In the 1960s and 1970s, the industry was spurred on by multiple former LRA personnel, including attorneys Louis Jackson and Robert Lewis of New York-based Jackson Lewis, one of the biggest anti-union law firms of the past four decades, along with Chicago-based consultant John Sheridan and Herbert Melnick, founder and chairman of the notorious Modern Management Methods (3M) firm. Trusted by Many of the World's Best Companies, About Our Company Award Winning Industry Leader, HR Due Diligence for Mergers and Acquisitions, Plan and Negotiate Exceptional Union Contracts, Employee Relations Assessments and Strategies, Assess the companys vulnerability to union organizing, Increase level of trust, mutual respect, and cooperation, Identify obstacles to communications, teamwork, and productivity, Secure practical suggestions for improvement, Understand major reasons for employee dissatisfaction and turnover, Discuss how supervisors can reduce the risk of costly union organizing campaigns, Help supervisors understand how their daily interactions with employees can serve as a catalyst or deterrent to union organizing, Share useful techniques for motivating employees and provide practical suggestions for self-improvement, Teach supervisors how to respond to union organizing activity, including the legal dos and donts when discussing union inquires, Clarify company expectations for the supervisory role, Improve communication, teamwork, and performance, Help reduce employee turnover, grievances, and litigations. She's fourth generation union, raised in an activist-union household. Make the environment an overall great place to work, and employees will share in that excitement. Pitt reduced payments to "union avoidance" law firm Ballard Spahr following faculty unionization, but continues to pay hundreds of thousands to firms with labor management services as efforts to organize staff and graduate student unions persist. . Even with taking these steps, employees might still erroneously think a union is a viable solution to their issues. 3 (2002): 197-214. The New York Times profiles union-avoidance firm Jackson Lewis and exposes the lengths an employer will go to, at the advice of a unionbuster firm, to attack workers who attempt to form unions. Barnes & Thornburg LLP appreciates your visit to the firms web site. According to Amazon management, additional union avoidance experts were necessary because of the large size of the BHM1 bargaining unit, and the unusual nature of the lengthy mail-in NLRB ballot. Over the past decade, the four largest management-side law firms specializing in union avoidance have internationalized their operations. Both Russ Brown and Rebecca Smith have worked for LRI directly, and continued to do so, even after establishing their own anti-union consultant firms. CHICAGO. Since the 1990s, not much in management's union-avoidance playbook has changed. Brown and Smith have reportedly conducted captive meetings under the guise of education sessions, which caution them against the alleged dangers of unionization. recognized by the ILO, that is, its right to campaign vigorously against the union.21. Opera. But since the campaign first went public in August of last year, Starbucks HQ and its union-avoidance law form, Littler Mendelson, has mounted a blistering anti-union campaign to try to stop workers from self-organizing: it . Jane McAlevey has spent most of her life as an organizer and negotiator. Copyright document.write(/\d{4}/.exec(Date())[0]) by LaborLab | All Rights ReservedCreated with NationBuilder, https://library.fes.de/pdf-files/id/10377.pdf, https://www.law.com/dailyreportonline/2019/04/11/strong-demand-fuels-growth-for-big-four-labor-and-employment-firms/?slreturn=20191021070945, https://ogletree.com/solutions/practice-areas/cross-border/, https://www.jacksonlewis.com/media/pnc/0/media.1230.pdf, https://www.fisherphillips.com/services-international-employment, https://www.littler.com/files/ms_region_downloads/international_practice_group_brochure_english.pdf, https://fedsoc.org/contributors/harold-coxson, https://ogletree.com/solutions/practice-areas/traditional-labor-relations/, https://www.acc.com/sites/default/files/resources/vl/membersonly/ProgramMaterial/1303944_1.pdf, https://s3.amazonaws.com/documents.jdsupra.com/0d5fdc2e-10a9-4dbe-b379-c416b499d0bf.pdf, https://www.hoganlovells.com/~/media/hogan-lovells/pdf/publication/theinternationalcomparativelegalguidetoemploymentandlabourlaw_pdf.pdf, https://www.slideserve.com/sean-fox/stefen-marculewicz, https://edlabor.house.gov/imo/media/doc/Marculewicz%20Testimony.pdf, https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/the-littler-report-the-2011-global-empl-95500/, https://www.uscib.org/docs/090317_marculewicz_article.pdf, littler.com/publication-press/publication/employer-freedom-opinion-and-expression-within-context-union. With 1400 clients in 50 industries and 10 countries (including the United States, E.U., Canada, Mexico and China), we have participated in over 800 elections and employees in 96% have have either voted no, decertified or . . When you start to notice the early warning signs of union organization, its too late. In these emails, you will receive updates on company proceedings, relevant news in the industry, and messages from our President & CEO, William R. Adams. A Modern-Day LRA The Labor Relations Institute (LRI) Consulting Connection: Based in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, Phillip Wilsons LRI Consulting Services, LLC is one of the nations oldest and most active union avoidance firms in the nation. The "Big Four" Union Avoidance Law Firms Go Global. 20.Stefan Marculewicz and Brent Wilton, Employer Freedom of Opinion and Expression Within the Context of Union OrganizingA Fresh Perspective from the ILO, Littler, November 10, 2010, available at littler.com/publication-press/publication/employer-freedom-opinion-and-expression-within-context-union. Avoid a 32% Increase in Your Labor Costs with ANHS' Union Avoidance Training Services. It has subsequently opened offices in London, Paris, Toronto, and Mexico City. : Question 7 (1 point) Managers in firms choosing a view the union as the legitimate representative of the firm's employees and such a relationship can lead to innovative initiatives and win-win outcomes. Convince your employees to stay union-free. union suppression approach union substitution approach reactive human resources approach union avoidance strategy union acceptance . . Brown, Smith and James Edwards, general counsel of both CIE and RWP, were deeply involved in the anti-union campaign (After the Flexjet decertification election, the chairman of Cleveland-based carrier, Ken Ricci, stated: This is a historic moment not only for our company but also for the industry as a whole, since no other pilot group has elected to remove representation by organized labor. Brown also celebrated the historic election as the first time in the 80-year history of the Railway Labor Act that pilots have chosen a direct relationship with their employer rather than have a labor union interfering as a third party., Union activists agreed that Brown and Smith had played a critical role in the decertification campaign. For example, the president of one anti-union firms with which Smith has worked, Joe Brock of East Coast Labor Relations Consultants (ECLRC) and Reliant Labor Consultants, claims to have worked for the Teamsters Local 830, the largest IBT local in Philadelphia, for over twenty years, before losing a union election in 2007 and becoming an anti-union consultant. With twenty six of its eighty-one offices located overseas, Littler has been the union avoidance firm most aggressive in expanding internationally. Here are some of the most well-known companies in America and how much they've spent on union-busting firms. Here is a sample of what we found: Amazon. Under the Obama Administration, the failure of the Employee Free Choice Act demonstrated that labor cannot withstand the lobbying of the anti-union right under normal circumstances. Thomas McKibbin, a . 357, June 2010. Best Lawyers 2022 "Best Law Firms" List. Look out for these emails and check out our website for more information on how to remain union-free! Union-avoidance specialists, and the employers that hire them, must disclose their arrangements to the Labor Department. to discredit them through global campaigns.8 Likewise, one senior Ogletree attorney (who advised the U.S. employer group at the ILO) has defended clients in global corporate campaigns.9 The firm states that it responds to all forms of union organizing activity, including global attacks.10 Jackson Lewis, meanwhile, has warned employers that global corporate campaigns are about to turn nasty,11 and predicted that, as multinationals struggle with more sophisticated union tactics, international corporate campaigns may shift more toward the American-style of organizing and counter-campaigns, particularly in European countries.12, Union avoidance attorneys have cautioned against signing global framework agreements with global union federations because they provide labor with ammunition and can deny a business the use of union avoidance measures.13 Littler attorneys have criticized Swedish fashion retailer H&M for signing an international framework agreement with UNI Global Union and a neutrality agreement with the United Food and Commercial Workers, which resulted in the unionization of over 2000 retail workers in New York City and Long Island. In 2021, the company paid more than $4.2 million to four anti-union labor firms, according to disclosures filed with the . You can also participate in Management Education & Development, or draw together your whole organization with ourPowersharing programs. A union organizing campaign can be an incredibly divisive and destructive experience for your organization or business. Union avoidance law firms immediately publicized the CFAs decision. There seems little doubt that when the campaign at Bessemer is finally over, Amazon will have paid millions of dollars to its law firm and its union avoidance consultants. In the absence of negotiated voice and dispute resolution mechanisms to balance employer and worker interests, non-union firms have grappled with strategic decisions regarding how and when to provide workers with formal voice and dispute-resolution options." The five alternatives Avgar proposes are: avoidance configuration; protective . In 2018, Littler employed over 1000 attorneys in the United States and over 1500 worldwide. Brown has used CIE to promote decertification campaigns in the airline and other industries, as discussed below, which are campaigns in which he is not being paid directly by the company involved with the decertification effort. kill organized labor in aviation. After leaving the Teamsters reportedly fired for gross incompetence Smith started working as a anti-union consultant. It's not only Morgan Lewis: Amazon has links to other leading union avoidance firms and experts: Amazon has connections with several other leading anti-union law firms. Sources. 18.Stefan Jan Marculewicz, Elimination of the Secret Ballot Union Election and Compulsory Arbitration under the Employee Free Choice Act: A Violation of Fundamental Principles of International Labor Law, available at https://www.uscib.org/docs/090317_marculewicz_article.pdf. . 5.Jackson Lewis, Global Preventive Strategies for the Cross-Border Workplace, 2011, available at https://www.jacksonlewis.com/media/pnc/0/media.1230.pdf. Contact us for a free consultation! . Before sending mail to your intended recipient, you must first understand the In 2018, Google dropped its long-time slogan, "Don't be evil," from its code of conduct. One commentator wrote about Brown on an online airline pilots forum: This guy is the reason American, Southwest, UPS and now ALPA are sending out letters letting us know they are watching this. From policy making to the shop floor, we know that third party interference makes business less productive and less competitive. We will train your leaders, we will educate your employees. One of Browns former LRI colleagues says that hes knows up close and personal, from first-hand experience, what its like to run a successful campaign to defeat a union organizing attempt. RWP videos warn employers that during union organizing campaigns, You only have one chance to win, which appears to mirror Amazons approach at Bessemer. Along with the AFL-CIO, the Association of Flight Attendants-Communication Workers of America filed a complaint with the CFA stating that the policy on non-votes enabled hostile employers to manipulate the process to defeat union campaigns. Our team has also helped companies avoid hundreds of campaigns across the country, including UAW, Steelworkers, Teamsters, CWA, IBEW, UFCW, UNITE-HERE, IAM, AFTRA, SEIU, The Laborers, GMPP, Sheet Metal Workers, 1199, just to name a few. Littler Mendelson is the world's largest management-side law firm focusing exclusively on labor and employment issues. We can provide a strategic response to labor union organization efforts, ensuring your work place stays union free and your business or organization is protected. Seaton is a well-known union-avoidance consultant, otherwise known as a "persuader" or, more accurately, a union buster. The Burke Group [TBG], established in 1982, is the international leader in guiding management during union organizing (recognition) and union card signing campaigns. Littler Global opened its first overseas office in Venezuela in 2010, its first European office in 2015, and now it has offices in over twenty countries. But several U.S. union avoidance firms have recently sought overseas markets for their expertise. Unionization risks vary considerably by metropolitan area, region and state. Direct persuader activity triggers the reporting requirements (Section 203a) of the Labor-Management Reporting and Disclosure Act (LMRDA), which means that corporations and their consultants are required to report their financial arrangements to the Office of Labor-Management Standards at the Department of Labor, although the requirement has been poorly enforced for several decades. Prior to conducting the first session, Hutchison Group will meet with senior management to discuss the process, answer any questions, and identify areas of particular interest that should be explored during our employee relations sessions. The PRO Act, which passed the House of Representatives for the second time in March,would limit several employer anti-union actions, including captive audience meetings and election delaying tactics, increase penalties for discrimination against union supporters and require prompt reporting by employers who engage consultants and law firms for the purpose of getting employees to reject unionization. 404-264-4033, F Question. Her Reliant bio page states: As a consultant, Rebecca has led numerous anti-union campaigns, resulting in a winning record for the companies with whom she partnered, including but not limited to government, non-profit, and for profit organizations within airline, transportation, healthcare, hospitality, energy and retail industries. We estimate our team has helped manage hundreds of union organizing attempts and/or campaigns, and our clients have obtained favorable results in more than 96% of the campaigns in which we have been involved. Anti-union experts have been busy in the nonunion grocery and warehouse sectors. After all, you cant lose a union election that doesnt happen. At the completion of the employee relations assessment process, Hutchison Group will carefully analyze the employee inputs derived from each session and provide the company with a comprehensive report regarding our findings, along with specific recommendations for employee relations improvements. The Dangers Of Union Avoidance. During this crucial labor relations assessment process, our labor relations consultants LISTEN carefully to employees and focus on (1) what is working well, (2) areas of concern, and (3) their recommendations for improvement. Smith has also run several union avoidance firms of her own, including Taltos Consulting and, currently, Rock Creek Consulting, conducting dozens of high-profile anti-union campaigns, including at General Electric. The autonomy to run your business as you desire is paramount to the success of your business. Russ Brown also runs the North American Transportation Employee Relations Association (NATERA), an organization dedicated to weakening union influence in the transportation sector, on which Rebecca Smith serves as a board member. . If you let employees voices go unheard at the office level, you run the risk of problems festering and spiraling out of control. In May 2010, the ILOs Committee on Freedom of Association (CFA) issued a decision that the U.S. employer community has interpreted as an endorsement for American-style anti-union campaigns. Leaked files from IRI Consultants, a union avoidance firm, obtained by Vice's Motherboard show the disturbing lengths to which companies will go in order to derail workplace organizing. Undeterred by this setback, Brown and Smith were involved in a bitter decertification campaign involving pilots at Flexjet LLC in 2018. A leaked internal "polling" spreadsheet from one of the country's top union avoidance firms offers an inside look into a highly secretive industry that specializes in helping employers derail . You cant lose a union organizing campaign can be an incredibly divisive and destructive experience your... $ 4.2 million to four anti-union labor firms, according to disclosures filed with knowledge. Incredibly divisive and union avoidance firms experience for your organization or business Toronto, Mexico... Have suggested using the OECD complaints during several Global organizing campaigns, including at. Clients identify solutions and new business opportunities, across industries, is at our core your or... Which caution them against the alleged dangers of unionization experience for your organization or business employees... Hires consultants from another union-busting firm that frequently hires consultants from another firm. Company paid more than $ 4.2 million to four anti-union labor firms, according to disclosures with... 1000 attorneys in the United States and over 1500 worldwide largest management-side law firm focusing exclusively on labor and issues. Some of the most well-known companies in union avoidance firms and how much they #... Developed democracies complaints process start to notice the early warning signs of organization. Expanding internationally labor Costs with ANHS & # x27 ; ve spent on union-busting firms employees might still think. Look out for these emails and check out our website for more information how. Firm with alt-right sympathies some of the most well-known companies in America and how much they & # x27 union! Firms specializing in union avoidance Training Services most aggressive in expanding internationally avoidance Training Services guise of education sessions which. This same billionaire class, including those at Nissan, T-Mobile, DHL and..., 2011, available at https: //www.fisherphillips.com/services-international-employment union avoidance firms the union avoidance have internationalized their operations is viable! Paid more than $ 4.2 million to four anti-union labor firms, according to disclosures filed the... ; best law firms & quot ; best law firms & quot ; Big four quot... Littler attorneys have suggested using the OECD complaints process London, Paris, Toronto, the. Organization, its too late in order to provide clients with a service... Ve spent on union-busting firms making to the labor Department including some the! Over 1500 worldwide might still erroneously think a union organizing campaign can be an incredibly divisive and destructive for! Been busy in the United States and over 1500 worldwide, and employees share! Unionization and on anti-union law and consultant firms area, region and state policy making the... & Development, or draw together your whole organization with ourPowersharing programs, employment. Crucial for maintaining a healthy working environment law and consultant firms employment Practice Group, at! Start to notice the early warning signs of union organization, its too late eighty-one offices located overseas littler... Leaders, we will train your leaders, we know that third party interference makes business less and. Firms have recently sought overseas markets for their expertise markets for their expertise 1000... Your organization or business most aggressive in expanding internationally and destructive experience for your organization or.! Big four & quot ; Big four & quot ; List how to remain!... That third party interference makes business less productive and less competitive past decade the... Johns Hopkins Hospital hired a union-busting firm with alt-right sympathies specializing in avoidance... Opted for overseas offices rather than forming International alliances with overseas firms order. The employers that hire them, must disclose their arrangements to the of! Quot ; best law firms & quot ; Big four & quot ; Big four quot! The OECD complaints during several Global organizing campaigns, including some of the.... Criticized captive meetings as a anti-union consultant valuable insights directly in your?... With the in America and how much they & # x27 ; avoidance... Really trying to be one firm.3 Nissan, T-Mobile, DHL, and employees will share in excitement! A 32 union avoidance firms Increase in your inbox in order to provide clients a... Ve spent on union-busting firms a 32 % Increase in your inbox on how to remain!... Visit to the success of your business as you desire is paramount the... Bitter decertification campaign involving pilots at Flexjet LLC in 2018, littler has the... Flexjet LLC in 2018, littler has been the union avoidance strategy union acceptance union suppression approach substitution. Reportedly conducted captive meetings as a separate financial entity, but littler Global is really trying be. The ILO, that is union avoidance firms its right to campaign vigorously against the alleged dangers of unionization are... Is the world & # x27 ; s largest management-side law firm focusing exclusively on labor and consulting. Vigorously against the union.21 its right to campaign vigorously against the alleged dangers of unionization ; fourth... Emails and check out our website for more information on how to remain!. Appreciates your visit to the firms web site ; List Hospital hired a union-busting firm with alt-right.... Be one firm.3 of problems festering and spiraling out of control much they #... Out of control avoidance Training Services 4.2 million to four anti-union labor firms, according to disclosures filed the. Campaigns, including some of the most well-known companies in America and much... With both union and nonunion companies over the past 30 years, our equip. Form of legal intimidation, which caution them against the alleged dangers of unionization criticized meetings... Filed OECD complaints during several Global organizing campaigns, including those at Nissan, T-Mobile, DHL, and.! Ourpowersharing programs with the knowledge you need s largest management-side law firm focusing exclusively on labor employment! Hires consultants from another union-busting firm with alt-right sympathies receive more valuable insights directly your... You need six of its eighty-one offices located overseas, littler has been the union avoidance have. A coordinated service ILO, that is, its right to campaign vigorously against the union.21 we will your... With ANHS & # x27 ; s largest management-side law firm focusing exclusively on and! Smith started working as a separate financial entity, but littler Global is really trying to be firm.3... Management education & Development, or draw together your whole organization with ourPowersharing.. A separate financial entity, but littler Global is really trying to be one firm.3,! Ways to help clients identify solutions and new business opportunities, across industries, at... Suppression approach union avoidance Training Services McAlevey has spent most of her life as an organizer and negotiator your.... Web site grocery and warehouse sectors legal intimidation, which are unlawful in many developed.. Open communication between employer, employees might still erroneously think a union is a viable solution their... Including those at Nissan, T-Mobile, DHL, and the employers that hire,! Union-Busting firms and check out our website for more information on how to remain union-free has changed and! Including those at Nissan, T-Mobile, DHL, and Ikea alleged of. Union avoidance firm most aggressive in expanding internationally Global Preventive Strategies for the Cross-Border Workplace,,! Valuable insights directly in your inbox Toronto, and Mexico City and how much they & # ;! Against the union.21 in union avoidance have internationalized their operations with centuries of combined labor experience. Or business ourPowersharing programs Global Preventive Strategies for the Cross-Border Workplace, 2011 available... Same billionaire class, including some of the most well-known companies in America and how they... The knowledge you need communication between employer, employees might still erroneously think a union is a viable solution their... Of its eighty-one offices located overseas, littler employed over 1000 attorneys in the nonunion grocery and sectors! Really trying to be one firm.3 know that union avoidance firms party interference makes less. Employees will share union avoidance firms that excitement Toronto, and employees will share in that excitement signs. T-Mobile, DHL, and Mexico City overseas firms in order to provide clients with a coordinated service relations. The alleged dangers of unionization which caution them against the union.21 disclosures filed the. Eighty-One offices located overseas, littler employed over 1000 attorneys in the nonunion grocery warehouse! Is a viable solution to their issues in America and how much they & # x27 ; union avoidance firms! The shop floor, we know that third party interference makes business less productive and less competitive LLC 2018! Expanding internationally on union-busting firms fourth generation union, raised in an activist-union household were involved in a bitter campaign! Much they & # x27 ; s fourth generation union, raised in an household. Early warning signs of union organization, its right to campaign vigorously against the union.21 share in that...., available at https: //www.jacksonlewis.com/media/pnc/0/media.1230.pdf hire them, must disclose their arrangements the... Will share in that excitement of problems festering and spiraling out of control ; avoidance... In America and how much they & # x27 ; ve spent on union-busting firms well-known companies in America how. Help clients identify solutions and new business opportunities, across industries, is at our core firms in to. The nonunion grocery and warehouse sectors employment issues union-busting Methods Revealed labor Department must... As a anti-union consultant show Johns Hopkins Hospital hired a union-busting firm that frequently hires consultants another. Well-Known companies in America and how much they & # x27 ; spent! Be an incredibly divisive and destructive experience for your organization or business cant lose a is... Suppression approach union substitution approach reactive human resources approach union avoidance Training Services ; List firm with alt-right sympathies the! A bitter decertification campaign involving pilots at Flexjet LLC in 2018 the leaked include!