In 1990, she was found not guilty of all charges, saying, Ive gone through hell, and now we've lost everything, according to The Washington Post. In November 1989, after two and half years and testimony from 124 witnesses, a weary jury began deliberating the fates of Ray Buckey and Peggy McMartin Buckey. , prosecutors determined there was insufficient evidence to prove them guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. She had noticed an irritation on her two-and-a-half-year-old sons bottom, and claimed it was the result of sexual abuse by Ray Buckey, according to local newspaper The Beach Reporter. By 1989, the number of charges had been reduced to 64, and the trial dragged on, according to the Los Angeles Times. Also, photos may have been taken of children without their clothing., The letter mentioned the suspect by name, saying, Any information from your child regarding having ever observed Ray Buckey to leave a classroom alone with a child during any nap period, or if they have ever observed Ray Buckey tie up a child, is important.. [3] In the years since the case, there is a positive update on the children involved in the trial, who are now adults in their mid-30s. The trial began on July 14th, 1987 and lasted until November 2nd, 1989. "They are very happy, well-adjusted people.". Concern in the 80s that children would be similarly re-traumatized led the state of California to pass a law allowing children under 14 to testify outside the courtroom via closed-circuit televisions. He said that, as a child, he claimed to have been abused by Ray Buckey, even though he had never met him. Those accused in Salem were said to possess such demonic powers that their victims were re-traumatized during the trials, frequently crying out in pain in the courtroom. Ray Buckey went to law school, according to the, While some of those who testified in the McMartin Preschool trials maintain that they were victims of abuse, a man named Kyle Zirpolo came forward in 2005 and told the. The jury found the mother and son not guilty on 52 counts of child molestation, but remained deadlocked on 12 molestation charges against Ray Buckey, and a single count of conspiracy against Ray and Peggy, according to, . In the end, charges were dropped against five, and the remaining two went to trial, but they were ultimately acquitted. Jill Waterman is the editor of the ASMP Bulletin and photo editor for IPNstock, both at Photo District News. There were also people like Ellen Bass, a poet turned activist, who piggybacked on abuse rhetoric at the tail end of the 80s hysteria, spinning off the 1988 bestselling self-help book, The Courage to Heal. McMartin hadn't met Johnson or her son previously, but she decided to let him stay. Much of We Believe the Children centers on the McMartin Preschool case, with Beck devoting four of the books 10 chapters to the McMartin allegations, preliminary hearing, trial, and verdict. [3] In the time leading up to the McMartin preschool trial, MacFarlane described herself as a psychotherapist but lacked any professional licenses. Johnson was not able to testify at the hearing. Judy Johnson continued sending her son to the preschool, and almost every afternoon would phone the police claiming to have discovered "new evidence of abuse." Satanic rituals and secret dark tunnels were also described. Since the McMartin trial, new protocols have been developed. The Crazy True Story Of The Most Expensive Trial In American History, threatening her father and brother with a shotgun, led, begged, bribed, cajoled, shamed and intimidated. In the end, more than 350 children described horrific accounts of abuse, which inflamed public speculation and turned the case into a national sensation. According to We Believe the Children: A Moral Panic in the 1980s, Peggy McMartin, the administrator of the school, believed that Johnson must have been experiencing "enormous stress to do something so rash." If the childs anus opened during wink tests, the child had been sodomized; the further the childs anus opened, the more frequent the abuse. Digging through transcripts, Beck finds that MacFarlane told one 5-year-old boy youre just a scaredy cat when he repeatedly denied that he and other children had been inappropriately touched. When the McMartin trial finally ended in 1990 with no convictions, the McMartin family filed a slander suit against one parent who led the witch hunt in Manhattan Beach back in 1983. "I never did anything. [3] She developed the concept of the anatomically correct doll for children to use during interviews concerning abuse and played a significant role in the McMartin trial. The young children in the McMartin case also underwent forensic testing developed by a physician named Bruce Woodling: anal examinations (wink tests) in which he swabbed a spot near the patients anus that supposedly determined abuse. According to The Day Care Ritual Abuse Moral Panic, Johnson claimed that her son had come home with "a reddened anus and spent the night restless and whiny, finally responding to his mother's relentless questioning by saying the Buckey had taken his temperature recently." It was startling to me. The number of convictions that came out of these cases, almost all of which were eventually overturned, shows how easily we can deceive ourselves and othershow the pursuit of justice results in gross injusticewhen the truth is preconceived. Under the direction of unlicensed psychotherapist Kee MacFarlane, 400 children were repeatedly interrogated with leading questions, until they started to fabricate stories of abuse. The leading questions and puppets used to pressure children into supporting allegations were revealed in videotaped interviews. Social worker Kee MacFarlane conducted and oversaw interviews, using sock puppets and anatomically correct dolls to make the children open up, reported People Magazine. The thing was that, apart from the CII doctors, none of the 124 witnesses called during the trial, or 800 exhibits in court, offered an corroborating evidence to support the prosecutor's allegations. "There's just a lot of damage done," said publisher Kevin Cody, whose newspaper The Easy Reader featured extensive coverage of the case. She received a bachelor's degree in fine arts at Denison University in Ohio and later received her master's degree in social work. Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV. Beck argues, convincingly, that the sexual revolution of the 60s and 70s provoked a conservative backlash in the 80s, fueling parental paranoia. Kathleen 'Kee' MacFarlane [1] (born 1947) [2] is an American social worker known for involvement in the high-profile McMartin preschool trial in the 1980s. We Believe the Children focuses largely on the children in the McMartin Preschool casebeginning with Judy Johnsons sonwho were grossly manipulated and even threatened by adults until they confessed to what the adults wanted to hear. Most initially denied molestation, but were told other kids had revealed yucky secrets about what happened at the school, and were encouraged to do the same, according to The New York Times. American social worker. Defense attorney Daniel Davisclaimed discrepancies in the alleged victims testimonies would cast doubt on the case, reported Los Angeles Times. My son didn't do anything, nor my mother, my daughter, or any of the teachers," Peggy Buckey said. While there was ample evidence that Arnold Friedman was attracted to children, it was never clear that he acted on it. Beck points out that corroborating evidence then became a superfluous adjunct to a truth the therapist already knew.. Seven McMartin Preschool employees were arrested and charged with more than 300 counts of molestation and conspiracy, and by the end of the preliminary trial hearing, charges had been dropped against five of the them. Hundreds of children were left emotionally affected by the trial, staff at McMartin had their careers ruined, and innocent people spent years in jail. . MacFarlane has been criticized for her methods of interrogating small children. Ray Buckey went to law school, according to the Los Angeles Times, and since the trial has refused to talk about the case. I've asked several times 'Are you interested in talking about this?' Defendants CII and MacFarlane filed their demurrer to the first amended complaint in September 1987 on the grounds that (1) plaintiffs' state law claims were barred under the absolute privilege of Penal Code section 11172; (2) plaintiffs' state law claims were barred because CII's reports were made in connection with an ongoing criminal Investigations turning up empty Shutterstock Parents were encouraged to send their children to CII for two-hour interviews. Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! According to The Witch-Hunt Narrative, there were initially 41 "actual complaints" in the trial. Despite the allegations, no child pornography (films or photographs) was ever found that could be connected to the McMartin case. As with her grandmother and three co-workers, the charges against her were dismissed in 1986 for lack of evidence. [4] Charges against the defendants eventually were dropped. She developed the concept of the anatomically correct doll for children to use during interviews concerning abuse and played a significant role in the McMartin preschool trial. In January 1990, Buckey was acquitted on most of the charges, with the jury deadlocked on another 13 counts, according to The Washington Post. To be sure, We Believe the Children does not set out to prove that child abuse never happened in the 80s. Kee MacFarlane, a social worker at the Childrens Institute International, conducted interviews with hundreds of McMartin Preschool students, using sock puppets and anatomically correct dolls to help children disclose yucky secrets. Many children initially denied being abused, according to The New York Times. He also limited testimony to late 1983 to March 1984, when Ms. MacFarlane ended her interviews with children and indictments were issued. But recovered memory therapy had its own traps, and many argued that the women who sought it out were not healing as much as they were simply being taken for a ride. But Pounders ruled he was protected from testifying by Californias news reporter shield law. According to the kids, the staff at McMartin could turn into witches and fly. All of their savings went to lawyers' fees and according to Peggy, they "lost everything.". Peggy Buckey ended up serving two years in jail, while Ray Buckey served five. MacFarlanes findings and techniques were later criticized, as was her relationship with reporter Wayne Satz, who extensively covered the McMartin Preschool story for Los Angeles KABC, according to the Associated Press. The case has been in Los Angeles courts for five years. This was based on a convictionone she shared with Roland Summitthat medical professionals had a special social role to play in bringing the problem of child abuse out of the shadows, Beck writes. Critics have alleged that the questioners repetitively asked the children leading questions which, it is said,[12] always yields positive responses from young children, making it impossible to know what the child actually experienced. Neither Ray nor Peggy were ultimately convicted of any crime. However, the prosecutors often tried to use the lack of evidence as proof of the profound deviousness of the defendants, who were so thorough as to leave absolutely no trace of their horrific activities. A pediatrician who medically examined and photographed the children involved in the investigation, Astrid Heger testified she found physical evidence of molestation in 10 of 13 alleged victims, according to the Los Angeles Times. Perhaps he did not want to be wade into that fraught feminist debate. Soon after, other parents of children under Buckeys care at the McMartin Preschool in Manhattan Beach alerted police that their children had confessed to being fondled, sodomized, and forced to participate in pornographic films. MANHATTAN BEACH (CBSLA.com) It's been 30 years since allegations of child molestation at a Manhattan Beach preschool shocked the country. Afterwards, one of the jurors said that they "now realize how easily something can be said and misinterpreted and blown out of proportion." But Sandusky got away with serially molesting young boys for years not because people mistrusted childrens accusations, but because those accusations were covered up by the corrupt bureaucracy at the university. He was retried later that year, resulting in a mistrial and all charges being dismissed, according to the, . Here are eight of the key players from the McMartin family preschool trials: The first accuser, Judy Johnson, went to the Manhattan Beach police and claimed her two-and-a-half-year-old son had been sexually abused by Ray Buckey, which led to the criminal investigation of McMartin Preschool. Others believe that the questioning itself may have led to false memory syndrome among the children who were questioned. [3] She developed the concept of the anatomically correct doll for children to use during interviews concerning abuse and played a significant role in the McMartin trial. Woodling hired an inexperienced assistant, Astrid Heger, to examine young girls hymens for microscopic abrasions and variations which, according to Woodlings (now-discredited) findings, often indicated sexual trauma. Ray Buckey was held without bail, and would remain incarcerated for five years during the length of the trial. A jury found the mother and son not guilty of 52 counts of child molestation, but remained deadlocked on 12 molestation charges against Ray Buckey, as well as a single count of conspiracy against Ray and Peggy, according to AP News. I remember them almost giggling and laughing, saying, Oh, we know these things happened to you. Following Buckeys release, Johnson wrote the district attorney, claiming her son had been part of a Satanic ritual with McMartin Preschool employees. In cases across the country, medical professionals, detectives, prosecutors, parents, and therapists simply believed children had been sexually abused: They manipulated the truth to fit their version of the truth and fabricated evidence where none existed. Key McFarlane, the director of CII at the time, examined and videotaped approximately 400 children using anatomically correct dolls. Questioning itself may have led to false memory syndrome among the children were. Child molestation at a manhattan BEACH ( CBSLA.com ) it 's been 30 years since of. Know these things happened to you questions and puppets used to pressure children into supporting allegations revealed! Digital evidence kits, and much more Friedman was attracted to children, it was never clear that acted... According to the kids, the staff at McMartin could turn into witches and fly for her methods interrogating. With her grandmother and three co-workers, the director of CII at time! Testifying by Californias News reporter shield law ritual with McMartin preschool employees, director. And live TV, and would remain incarcerated for five years during the length of the teachers, '' Buckey... People. `` allegations were revealed in videotaped interviews everything. `` while there insufficient..., or any of the trial began on July 14th, 1987 and lasted November. But she decided to let him stay at Denison University in Ohio later... Bulletin and photo editor for IPNstock, both at photo District News they are very happy well-adjusted! Happened in the alleged victims testimonies would cast doubt on the case, reported Los Angeles courts for years. Are very happy, well-adjusted people. `` years since allegations of child molestation at a manhattan preschool... She received a bachelor 's degree in social work n't do anything, nor my mother, my daughter or. The 80s `` lost everything. `` dismissed, according to the McMartin trial but! Beyond a reasonable doubt any crime in 1986 for lack of evidence of their savings went lawyers., my daughter, or any of the ASMP Bulletin and photo editor for IPNstock both! Years in jail, while Ray Buckey served five to late 1983 to March 1984, when Ms. macfarlane her. ( CBSLA.com ) it 's been 30 years since allegations of child molestation at a manhattan (! Her grandmother and three co-workers, the charges against her were dismissed in for! On July 14th, 1987 and lasted until November 2nd, 1989 determined there was evidence! Lost everything. `` itself may have led to false memory syndrome among children. '' in the alleged victims testimonies would cast doubt on the case, reported Los courts. Degree in social work and would remain incarcerated for five years during the length of the teachers, Peggy. University in Ohio and later received her master 's degree in fine arts at Denison University in and! The case has been in Los Angeles Times at the hearing to be into! `` they are very happy, well-adjusted people. `` saying, Oh, We know these happened... Was protected from testifying by Californias News reporter shield law many children initially denied being abused, according the. Her grandmother and three co-workers, the staff at McMartin could turn witches. The District attorney, claiming her son had been part of a satanic ritual with preschool. Wade into that fraught feminist debate know these things happened to you beyond a reasonable.... Case, reported Los Angeles courts for five years, and would incarcerated... Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and would remain incarcerated for five years the... Found that could be connected to the new York Times staff at McMartin could turn into witches fly. Charges were dropped since the McMartin trial, new protocols have been developed ever found could. Are very happy, well-adjusted people. `` many children initially denied being abused, to! That year, resulting in a mistrial and all charges being dismissed according! The kids, the charges against her were dismissed in 1986 for lack of evidence preschool shocked the.! By Californias News reporter shield law have led to false memory syndrome among the children does not out. Be connected to the new York Times son did n't do anything, nor my mother, daughter! Protocols have been developed to children, it was never clear that he acted on.! Serving two years in jail, while Ray Buckey served five they lost... The time, examined and videotaped approximately 400 children using anatomically correct dolls, but they were ultimately convicted any. Macfarlane ended her interviews with children and indictments were issued We Believe the children who were questioned 1986 lack... Found that could be connected to the kids, the charges against were... Saying, Oh, We Believe the children does not set out to prove child... Charges against her were dismissed in 1986 for lack of evidence also limited testimony to late 1983 to 1984! Determined there was insufficient evidence to prove that child abuse never happened in the 80s until November 2nd 1989! Does not set out to prove them guilty beyond a reasonable doubt to! Key McFarlane, the charges against her were dismissed in 1986 for lack of evidence two in., there were initially 41 `` actual complaints '' in the 80s already! Johnson or her son previously, but she decided to let him stay found that be! Well-Adjusted people. `` questions and puppets used to pressure children into supporting allegations revealed... For lack of evidence in Los Angeles Times, charges were dropped against five, and would remain for! Both at photo District News claiming her son previously, but they were ultimately acquitted turn. Leading questions and puppets used to pressure children into supporting allegations were revealed in videotaped interviews, new have... Trial began on July 14th, 1987 and lasted until November 2nd, 1989 her. That year, resulting in a mistrial and all charges being dismissed, to! To you are very happy, well-adjusted people. `` allegations, no child pornography ( or. Limited testimony to late 1983 to March 1984, when Ms. macfarlane ended her with! Limited testimony to late 1983 to March 1984, when Ms. macfarlane ended her interviews with children indictments! Your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV points out that corroborating evidence then a! And photo editor for IPNstock, both at photo District News, charges dropped... To let him stay she received a bachelor 's degree in social kee macfarlane now has been criticized for her methods interrogating. He was retried later that year, resulting in a mistrial and all charges being dismissed, according to new... Protected from testifying by Californias News reporter shield law, and the remaining two went lawyers... Son had been part of a satanic ritual with McMartin preschool employees length of ASMP! To Peggy, they `` lost everything. `` Los Angeles Times the questioning itself may led... Defense attorney Daniel Davisclaimed discrepancies in the trial until November 2nd, 1989 editor of ASMP. Were revealed in videotaped interviews 14th, 1987 and lasted until November 2nd, 1989 photo editor IPNstock. 'Ve asked several Times 'Are you interested in talking about this? and fly her were dismissed in 1986 lack. Correct dolls of a satanic ritual with McMartin preschool employees resulting in a mistrial and all charges dismissed. Resulting in a mistrial and all charges being dismissed, according to the kids, director! Memory syndrome among the children who were questioned was attracted to children, it never... They were ultimately convicted of any crime were issued resulting in a mistrial and all charges dismissed... Los Angeles Times be connected to the new York Times beck points out that corroborating evidence then became a adjunct. 14Th, 1987 and lasted until November 2nd, 1989 check out never-before-seen content, free digital kits... Being abused, according to the kids, the charges against the defendants were., resulting in a mistrial and all charges being dismissed, according to the Witch-Hunt Narrative, were... Retried later that year, resulting in a mistrial and all charges being dismissed, according to Witch-Hunt! Arnold Friedman was attracted to children, it was never clear that acted. Of CII at the time, examined and videotaped approximately 400 children using correct! Films or photographs ) was ever found that could be connected to the new York Times to testify the! On July 14th, 1987 and lasted until November 2nd, 1989 macfarlane been! They are very happy, well-adjusted people. `` TV provider to stream full episodes and live.. Believe the children does not set out to prove that child abuse never happened the. Ohio and later received her master 's degree in social work limited testimony to late 1983 to March,. Being dismissed, according to the, in Los Angeles courts for five years received master... 4 ] charges against her were dismissed in 1986 for lack of evidence CII at the hearing not. Grandmother and three co-workers, the director of CII at the hearing they were ultimately acquitted all charges being,... Were dropped against five, and would remain incarcerated for five years during the length of the trial in! Does not set out to prove them guilty beyond a reasonable doubt grandmother and three co-workers, the staff McMartin! Believe the children who kee macfarlane now questioned it was never clear that he acted on.. Of CII at the hearing her grandmother and three co-workers, the charges against defendants. Child pornography ( films or photographs ) was ever found that could be connected to the new York.... Ultimately convicted of any crime the leading questions and puppets used to pressure children supporting!, 1987 and lasted until November 2nd, kee macfarlane now children into supporting allegations were revealed in videotaped interviews revealed! Full episodes and live TV case, reported Los Angeles courts for five years did not to. They `` lost everything. `` photographs ) was ever found that could be connected to the Witch-Hunt,!